Shuck and Jive


Wednesday, September 15, 2010

A Slow News Week for the LayMAN





The LayMAN has decided to take a few shots at the new vice-moderator of the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.), Rev. Landon Whitsitt.





In a meandering post that moves from wikipedia to crowdsourcing to Phyllis Tickle, former editor of the LayMAN, Parker Williamson, has gone on a Whitsitt hunt.

The Holy One of Lenoir explains Whitsitt's "world":

What’s lacking, of course, is our refusal to acknowledge any authority above ourselves. We’re talking here of a world without God, a world that does not – will not – hear “Thus says the Lord,” a world where “crowdsourcing” is all there is.

This is the world that the Presbyterian Church (USA)’s vice moderator embraced when shortly after the General Assembly adjourned, he opined that “Scripture is no longer an authority.”
To get what Parker is talking about, you have to follow his link to another LayMAN article entitled: PCUSA Vice-Moderator: "Scripture is Not the Word of God".

I have to say the title alone is enough to make me admire Whitsitt. At most "Word of God" is a metaphorical combination. I personally think it does more harm than good and that we should stop using it as I wrote here.

I am not sure that is where Landon is. I'd hate to see the poor guy sent to hell because I have praised him. Finally, after working through the links I find the the source of the damning quote, an interview with Whitsitt shortly after he took office, A Leader Rethinks Church. Yet this is all I found:

'Sola Scriptura' is dead most places, and dying rapidly in others. So where do we lodge the authority of our faith? That's the real battle we see fought in the church. We're not really arguing about LGBT (Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender) inclusion, we're arguing about how we read the Bible.
I still haven't found where he said, "Scripture is not the Word of God."

Maybe he said, "Scripture is not the Word of God" somewhere else or maybe the LayMAN is just telling an Appalachian tall tale. They are common in these parts.

Landon's quote about sola scriptura is interesting. I personally think he is doing a good thing for the church. I wonder if the difference between the "worlds" of Parker and Landon is the difference between understanding faith as clinging to a slogan and repeating it vs. reflecting on what it means and making some decisions about its usefulness.

Good job, Landon. These are questions the church needs to talk about even if it is brought into the conversation kicking and screaming.


UPDATE: OK, I think I found it. At the end of the first LayMAN article, it reads:
Whitsitt added that he believes Jesus Christ is the final authority, and the disagreement over Scripture is on how it’s read and at what point it should be authoritative.

“What I’m trying to do is place Scripture at a specific point in the process of trying to discern what the Word of God would have us do,” he said. “Scripture is only a reference point to the Word of God, it’s not the Word of God, you know, capital W. It’s only a reference point.”
That is not the same as declaring as the title did: "Scripture is not the Word of God."

What Whitsitt is saying is pretty standard stuff. I mean what else can a metaphor do but point?

Monday, September 13, 2010

It's Cause I Love Ya

That I think you might want to watch this film and share it with family and friends. Then ask if you are ready spiritually and emotionally for

A Crude Awakening: The Oil Crash

You can watch it on your computer right now:


Meaning of Life, Part 61


Mike Ruppert has condensed his core beliefs into four "compass points" that provide direction for the "map" of the global industrialized society. This is his view in a nutshell of where we are and where we are going.


NORTH – A NEW, SUSTAINABLE HUMAN PARADIGM MUST BE ROOTED IN LOCAL, CHEMICAL-FREE FOOD PRODUCTION, EXTENDED FAMILY AND COMMUNITY

The two primary and most visible points of contact between humans and the earth are where one sleeps and where one’s food originates. Our future relations with each other and the planet will be governed by distance and a return to ways of life that allowed our species to survive in a pre-industrial world, and preserving and adapting technology to a new set of priorities. Local food production will become the foundation of human experience, art and culture.

Chemical-free agriculture and Permaculture are the most effective, direct and unfiltered forms of exchange with the planet. They will enable the largest numbers of people to survive the transition between old and new paradigms. Since everything that we eat and wear was once alive and since all life originates from the earth, it follows that our relationship with our ecosystem is of primary importance.


There will be bigger risks, pain, suffering and loss throughout the transition. Yet there will also be a rediscovery of infinitely greater possibilities for joy and the fullest-possible expression of the human soul.


SOUTH – UNTIL THE WAY MONEY WORKS CHANGES, OUR SPECIES IS TRAPPED IN AN INFINITE-GROWTH PARADIGM WHICH THREATENS ALL LIFE

There is a 96% correlation between GDP growth and greenhouse gas emissions resulting from the burning of fossil fuels. – The current economic paradigm centered around the “personhood” of corporations and founded upon fractional reserve banking, compound interest and fiat currency is, by definition, a pyramid scheme and unsustainable. – It is more profitable to destroy life under this paradigm than it is to save it.


This dying monetary paradigm is for now the dominant factor governing relationships with the planet. There are but two options for those wishing to survive: Change that paradigm or disengage from it to the maximum extent possible and allow the old paradigm to wither and pass. It is not possible to change the monetary paradigm. Therefore, disengagement is essential as the old paradigm collapses. Disengagement to whatever degree possible will become a matter of life and death, and perhaps the survival of our species.


Money will be completely redefined. Establishment of local and regional currencies or mediums of exchange outside the control or influence of the current paradigm is an essential step in disengagement.

EAST – INFINITE GROWTH ON A FINITE PLANET IS NOT POSSIBLE

Everything humans eat, breathe, drink, wear and consume is taken from the earth. There is an inherently sustainable balance point for human population – influenced by its lifestyle – and the earth.

Cheap and easy-to-obtain fossil-fuel energies (coal, oil and natural gas) are depleting rapidly. Energy that has allowed for the extraction, manufacture and transportation of everything consumed by humans is disappearing. Oil and natural gas are not just energy sources. All plastics, fertilizers, pesticides and most pharmaceuticals, lotions, paints, resins, cosmetics and many other products depend on chemical input from oil and natural gas. These chemical inputs cannot be replaced by alternative energies. – There are ten calories of fossil-fuel energy in every calorie of food consumed in the industrialized world. Food production, with fossil-fuel input, has enabled the earth’s population to grow by more than five billion people in the last 150 years. If the fossil fuels go away, the food goes away, leaving depleted, chemically-dependent topsoil behind. – All other life-essential resources, especially fresh water, are under severe stress.


It is not possible to change the energy infrastructure to an unknown combination of alternatives because we have waited too long and there is no combination of alternative energies capable of supporting the edifice built by fossil fuels.

Population and ecological balance will be restored whether humans participate or not. Active, conscious participation can mitigate consequences. Destroying the ecosystem we live in and failing to adjust and reprioritize our use of resources is, therefore, suicidal behavior. Change must happen from the bottom up and individually from the inside out before it can happen from community and cultural levels with increased effectiveness.


WEST – HUMAN POPULATION WILL INEVITABLY REDUCE BY BILLIONS OF PEOPLE AMIDST GREAT SUFFERING AS THE SUN SETS ON INDUSTRIAL CIVILIZATION


The Die Off, as it is called, is an integral part of the irreversible collapse of human industrial civilization. It cannot be avoided. It can only be mitigated. It may be that from this Die Off and transition, a new consciousness will arise among humans or in fact, a new kind of human species: Post-Petroleum Man.

--Michael Ruppert's Collapsenet

Can You Say "Collapse"?


Collapse.


A helpful exercise is to the say the word. Hear yourself say it.

Collapse. Again.

Collapse. You can do this.

Collapse.

I am pleased that Robert Jensen can say it. I have written about Robert Jensen before especially in the context of Presbyterian mini-dramas. He is the atheist guy who joined the church. Those were good times.

Robert Jensen was interviewed by the New Left Project. The interview is entitled: A World in Collapse? Good for Robert Jensen. He is saying the "C" word. We need to be able to say it.

Industrial civilization is collapsing. We cannot stop it. However, we can creatively and consciously respond to it. We can only respond if we overcome denial. This is as much if not more a spiritual, emotional, social, and psychological challenge as it is a material and political one.

That is the task of clergy. I'm looking at you.

Obviously, it is not only the task of clergy. It is the task of all of us. However, clergy, given their role should be the ones to
  1. tell the truth
  2. provide opportunities for people to come to terms with grief
  3. encourage people to prepare and be conscious
But mostly we reinforce denial and engage in trivial skirmishes. Why is that? Jensen may have some insight:
I’ve had many left colleagues tell me that they agree with some or all of my analysis, but that “people aren’t ready to hear that yet.” I translate that to mean, “I’m not ready to hear that yet.” I think a lot of leftists displace their own fear of confronting these difficult realities onto “the masses,” when in fact they can’t face it.
I am trying to think of all the reasons that keep me from telling the truth regarding the collapse of industrial civilization to my church folks:
  1. They might believe it and stop giving to the church.
  2. They might take their anger out on the messenger.
  3. They might think I am an apocalyptic yahoo and leave.
  4. I may need to face my own anxieties and fears.
  5. I may not have the skills or strength to minister in time of collapse.
  6. I am still mostly in denial.
If I were truly honest, there are probably more reasons. But that is all I can handle today.

I am grateful today for Robert Jensen, Carolyn Baker, and Michael Ruppert.

I just realized that today is September 13th. On September 13th, 1992 I was ordained by the Presbytery of Utica (New York) and installed as minister at my first call, FPC Lowville, NY.

What a long strange trip it has been.

UPDATE: Here is the podcast of Mike Ruppert's first show on the Progressive Radio Network, The Lifeboat Hour.

Sunday, September 12, 2010

Our New Imperial Religion

I keep wondering about the "no stories"-- the so called mosque at ground zero and the guy who either did or didn't (I can't keep up) burn a Qur'an for our new High Holy Day, September 11th.

September 11th has become America's Good Friday. We celebrate victimization at the hands of the Muslim Horde. Not even our gadzillion dollar defense system could defend our skies against these evil geniuses.

We must pull out all the stops and go after these demons, these radical Muslims--these terrorists. With ritual and superstition usually reserved for the faithful, we remember 9/11. As medieval Christians remembered Good Friday as the day "the Jews killed our Lord" so we remember September 11th as the day when "Radical Muslims attacked our Freedoms."

Just mix in some hocus pocus and little holy juice and you got yourself a new religion.

Here are a couple of thoughtful pieces by Michel Chossudovsky. I think he nails it:


September 11th, 2008, 9/11 and The American Inquisition.

"The Global War on Terrorism" (GWOT) is presented as a "Clash of Civilizations", a war between competing values and religions, when in reality it is an outright war of conquest, guided by strategic and economic objectives.

The GWOT is the ideological backbone of the American Empire. It defines US military doctrine, including the preemptive use of nuclear weapons against the "state sponsors" of terrorism.

The preemptive "defensive war" doctrine and the "war on terrorism" against Al Qaeda constitute essential building blocks of America’s National Security Strategy as formulated in early 2002. The objective is to present "preemptive military action" —meaning war as an act of "self-defense" against two categories of enemies, "rogue States" and "Islamic terrorists", both of which are said to possess weapons of mass destruction.

The logic of the "outside enemy" and the evildoer, allegedly responsible for American civilian deaths, prevails over common sense. In the inner consciousness of Americans, the attacks of September 11, 2001 justify acts of war and conquest....

....Washington does not silence its antiwar critics. Quite the opposite. The inquisitorial social order allows certain forms of dissent. It is politically correct under a "democracy" to condemn US foreign policy in the strongest terms.

What is not allowed is to question the inquisition.

Those who oppose the US Administration are not branded as heretics. Many "Progressives", Liberals and Antiwar activists, led by prominent intellectuals, firmly believe that Muslims were behind the 9/11 attacks. "We are against the war, but we support the war on terrorism."

The New World Order builds a political and media consensus (i.e. the GWOT) but at the same time it creates and moulds its own opposition. It establishes the limits of dissent. It "manufactures dissent".

The presidential candidates in the bipartisan race are supported by powerful corporate interests including the oil companies, Wall Street and the defense contractors.

At the same time, these same corporate interests, through their various foundations (including Ford, Rockefeller, Gates, et al), support and finance a number of Liberal/Progressive organizations and alternative media.

9/11 is the cornerstone of the American Inquisition.

The lies underlying 9/11 are accepted by the mainstream antiwar movement.

US foreign policy is condemned, but the "Global War on Terrorism" is upheld. Wittingly or unwittingly, this endorsement of the GWOT by those who claim to be opposed to the US administration, provides a legitimacy to the inquisitorial order, which underlies the actual practice of US foreign policy.

On the other hand, those who have serious doubts regarding the official 9/11 narrative, including the 9/11 Truth Movement, are branded as heretics and nonbelievers.
January 4th 2007, The "Demonization" of Muslims and the Battle for Oil.
Demonization is a PSYOP, used to sway public opinion and build a consensus in favor of war. Psychological warfare is directly sponsored by the Pentagon and the US intelligence apparatus. It is not limited to assassinating or executing the rulers of Muslim countries, it extends to entire populations. It also targets Muslims in Western Europe and North America. It purports to break national consciousness and the ability to resist the invader. It denigrates Islam. It creates social divisions. It is intended to divide national societies and ultimately trigger "civil war". While it creates an environment which facilitates the outright appropriation of the countries' resources, at the same time, it potentially backlashes, creates a new national consciousness, develops inter-ethnic solidarity, brings people together in confronting the invaders.
Genuflect and carry on.

Creation: In the Right Time--A Sermon

Today was Music Sunday. I am blessed to serve an incredibly gifted bunch of folks. The music was fantastic. We mixed it with some poetry, and I included a poem of sorts that I had put together over ten years ago.

Creation: In the Right Time
May 30th, 1999
August 28th, 2005 (revised)
September 12th, 2010 (revised)

John Shuck
First Presbyterian Church
Elizabethton, TN

"The most important question before us is whether the universe is friendly.”
--Albert Einstein

“And God saw that it was good.”
--a refrain from Genesis 1

In the beginning…
Is there a beginning?
Before beginnings,
Before time,
Outside of space—
In the right time,
When Mystery began to move,
A small speck,
Smaller than an electron,
Smaller than a quark,
A tiny speck existed.
This tiny particle contained all the mass and energy of existence.

Mystery moved and the particle exploded
And the Universe burst forth.

Time and space,
All that is…became.
In a flash of energy,
In a flash of light,
In a vibration of sound,
Ten to the billionth power of an atomic explosion
Is but a drop in the ocean

Compared to the energy created by Mystery.

Cascading light,
And searing heat danced around and around and out.
Spinning and twirling for millions of years—
The fireworks of Mystery,
Dancing to its symphony.
In the right time these dancers gathered
Gathered and gathering,
Collecting,
Attracting,
Repelling,
Neutrons, protons, electrons
Hydrogen and Helium forming in the right time
Balls of light and heat
Pulling and pushing mass and energy into their dance.
Stars and planets and solar systems and galaxies
Danced to the music of Mystery.

They found their rhythms,
Their paths and their orbits and their place.

In the right time,
Certain solar systems and certain planets
because of their size and the distance from their suns,
were found suitable for something more.
One such planet,
An ordinary blue dot in the suburbs of the Milky Way gave birth.

(There may be many other planets who are also life-giving—
Maybe someday those who wonder will be rewarded—
In the right time—
But for now we know of this one.)

Mystery moved,
And this one planet,
The third from its sun,
Was covered with a thick organic soup.
Hydrogen and Oxygen combined in the right parts,
And Carbon swam with them and the basics of Life joined the dance.

As Mystery moved through the soup,
millions and millions of complex organisms were born.
They all knew a different song and they lived and they died.
Some species survived,
Some did not.
All in their time.

In the right time, the land masses formed,
The continents shifted,
Foliage appeared and new creatures were formed and
Moved from water to land.


Time passed and Mystery kissed the earth—
Slowly, slowly, hundreds of millions of years passed.
Life changed little by little,
Finally, huge beasts joined the dance.
The Triceratops and the Brontosaurus,
Pterodactyls and Tyrannosaurus Rex

Lumbered to the music of Mystery.
And these great beasts ruled the earth,
Until nature shifted, and the time came when they were no more.

Mystery moved through all the changes of creation,
Sometimes suddenly, usually slowly,
New species evolved from older species

In the right time,
The hominoids evolved from their ancestors.
They struggled and they changed and adapted to their surroundings.
Mystery moved through all these changes and
Blessed these creatures.

As they were ready in the right time,
They developed skills to master their surroundings.
They discovered tools, fire, and communication.
They developed abstractions like thought, reflection,
wonder, puzzlement, love, and

A desire to seek Mystery.

Mystery blessed this desire and sought out those humans
Who were sensitive to Mystery to tell stories about who they were,
And how they came to be, and what they might yet do.
People like Abraham and Sarah, Rachel and Jacob told their story.

Mystery was called by different names in
Different languages in different places—

The Great Spirit, Marduk, the Goddess, Brahman,
The Holy One of Israel, God, Christ, Allah,
The No-Thing, the Ground of Being.
But Mystery is elusive, not allowing a name to tame it,
Allowing no human to claim it for a possession.

Mystery allows but a glimpse, a darkened mirror.
Yet Mystery blesses all who seek, who quest for the truth.
Mystery seeks out those who are sensitive to it.
Sometimes Mystery calls us through stillness—
Silent as a Spruce stretching for the sun—
Sometimes is speaks in the cries of the hungry and destitute—
Sometimes it rolls with easy laughter.
Mystery moves—as Earth changes, as the Universe changes—
As human beings change.
Mystery shows us that there is much more than what we see.
There is much, much more to come.

In the right time.

And it is good.

Saturday, September 11, 2010

Ruppert on the Radio


I am looking forward to the debut of
Michael Ruppert's new radio show, The Lifeboat Hour.


It will air Sunday nights at 9 pm Eastern on the
Progressive Radio Network. If you think Mike Ruppert is just a gloom and doomer, check again:

This is Michael C. Ruppert. I want to tell you about my new radio show, “The Lifeboat Hour” which debuts Sunday September 12th on The Progressive Radio Network, right after Gary Null.

What could possibly be uplifting, liberating or encouraging about Peak Oil, universal cutbacks, climate change, environmental destruction and the collapse of industrial civilization? -- The answer is… “A lot”.

After all my years of work as an author, journalist and activist trying to warn people of a collapse that is now upon us, I'm happy to report that I have a new job. I'm a student again. Did you know that around the world millions of people are actively finding ways to live outside of the corporate-controlled paradigm of infinite growth, pyramid schemes, peak energy, ecosystem destruction, job loss, banking collapse and "The End of the World as We Know It"? Have you been longing for someone... anyone, to show you a way of life that might free you from feeling trapped by it all? Well, your wait is over.

On September 12th I will be premiering a new show on the largest Internet radio network in the world, PRN. You may have read my books or seen me in the movies. But I can guarantee that what you'll hear and experience on The Lifeboat Hour is anything but drudgery, gloom and defeatism. I'll also be featuring music from my band, New White Trash that's fresh, original and finally something all about the world we're living in today. New White Trash will release its new Double CD "Double Wide" on September 12th, with our first selections being played on the broadcast. We felt it's time we all got something from music and entertainment that actually talks about the world we're in now; something that gives energy and puts spring in the step without telling us lies. The final mix and mastering of NWT's music has been completed by the legendary Bob Rice, whose last project before our was for Roger Waters of Pink Floyd.

-- Join me on the Lifeboat Hour, Sundays at 9 PM Eastern, where we’ll mix original music with the madness; laughter with loss, skills with sorrow, community with calamity, love with grief, and joy in the moment.


<a href="http://newwhitetrash.com/album/doublewide">DOUBLEWIDE by New White Trash</a>

UPDATE Here is the podcast of his first show on The Lifeboat Hour.

A Moment of Silence



Before I start this poem
by Emmanuel Ortiz

Before I start this poem,
I'd like to ask you to join me in
a moment of silence
in honour of those who died
in the World Trade Centre
and the Pentagon
last September 11th.

I would also like to ask for
a moment of silence
for all of those who have been
harassed, imprisoned, disappeared,
tortured, raped, or killed
in retaliation for those strikes,
for the victims in both
Afghanistan and the U.S.

And if I could just add one more thing...
A full day of silence
for the tens of thousands of Palestinians
who have died at the hands of
U.S.-backed Israeli forces
over decades of occupation.

Six months of silence
for the million and-a-half Iraqi people,
mostly children, who have died of
malnourishment or starvation
as a result of an 11-year U.S. embargo
against the country.

Before I begin this poem:
two months of silence
for the Blacks under Apartheid
in South Africa,
where homeland security
made them aliens
in their own country.

Nine months of silence
for the dead in Hiroshima
and Nagasaki, where death rained
down and peeled back
every layer of concrete, steel, earth and skin
and the survivors went on as if alive.

A year of silence
for the millions of dead
in Vietnam--a people, not a war-
for those who know a thing or two
about the scent of burning fuel,
their relatives' bones buried in it,
their babies born of it.

A year of silence
for the dead in Cambodia and Laos,
victims of a secret war ... ssssshhhhh ....
Say nothing ... we don't want them to
learn that they are dead.

Two months of silence
for the decades of dead
in Colombia, whose names,
like the corpses they once represented,
have piled up and slipped off
our tongues.

Before I begin this poem,
An hour of silence
for El Salvador ...
An afternoon of silence
for Nicaragua ...
Two days of silence
for the Guetmaltecos ...
None of whom ever knew
a moment of peace
45 seconds of silence
for the 45 dead
at Acteal, Chiapas
25 years of silence
for the hundred million Africans
who found their graves
far deeper in the ocean
than any building could
poke into the sky.
There will be no DNA testing
or dental records
to identify their remains.
And for those who were
strung and swung
from the heights of
sycamore trees
in the south, the north,
the east, and the west...

100 years of silence...
For the hundreds of millions of
indigenous peoples
from this half of right here,
Whose land and lives were stolen,
In postcard-perfect plots
like Pine Ridge,
Wounded Knee,
Sand Creek, Fallen Timbers,
or the Trail of Tears.
Names now reduced
to innocuous magnetic poetry
on the refrigerator
of our consciousness ...
So you want a moment of silence?

And we are all left speechless
Our tongues snatched from our mouths
Our eyes stapled shut
A moment of silence
And the poets have all been laid to rest
The drums disintegrating into dust

Before I begin this poem,
You want a moment of silence
You mourn now as if the world will never be
the same
And the rest of us hope to hell it won't be.
Not like it always has been

Because this is not a 9-1-1 poem
This is a 9/10 poem,
It is a 9/9 poem,
A 9/8 poem,
A 9/7 poem
This is a 1492 poem.
This is a poem about
what causes poems like this
to be written

And if this is a 9/11 poem, then
This is a September 11th poem
for Chile, 1971
This is a September 12th poem
for Steven Biko in South Africa, 1977

This is a September 13th poem
for the brothers at Attica Prison,
New York, 1971.
This is a September 14th poem
for Somalia, 1992.

This is a poem
for every date that falls
to the ground in ashes
This is a poem for the 110 stories
that were never told
The 110 stories that history
chose not to write in textbooks
The 110 stories that CNN, BBC,
The New York Times,
and Newsweek ignored
This is a poem
for interrupting this program.
And still you want
a moment of silence
for your dead?
We could give you
lifetimes of empty:

The unmarked graves
The lost languages
The uprooted trees and histories
The dead stares on the faces
of nameless children
Before I start this poem
We could be silent forever
Or just long enough to hunger,
For the dust to bury us
And you would still ask us
For more of our silence.

If you want a moment of silence
Then stop the oil pumps
Turn off the engines and the televisions
Sink the cruise ships
Crash the stock markets
Unplug the marquee lights,
Delete the instant messages,
Derail the trains, the light rail transit
If you want a moment of silence,
put a brick through
the window of Taco Bell,
And pay the workers for wages lost
Tear down the liquor stores,
The townhouses, the White Houses,
the jailhouses, the Penthouses and
the Playboys.

If you want a moment of silence,
Then take it
On Super Bowl Sunday,
The Fourth of July
During Dayton's 13 hour sale
Or the next time your white guilt
fills the room where my beautiful
people have gathered

You want a moment of silence
Then take it
Now,
Before this poem begins.

Here, in the echo of my voice,
In the pause between goosesteps of the
second hand
In the space
between bodies in embrace,

Here is your silence.
Take it.
But take it all
Don't cut in line.
Let your silence begin
at the beginning of crime.
But we,
Tonight we will keep right on singing
For our dead.

Emmanuel Ortiz works with the Minnesota Alliance for the Indigenous Zapatistas (MAIZ) and Estación Libre. He is a staff member of the Resource Centre of the Americas, the non-profit publisher of americas.org

h/t Snad

Michael Ruppert

I am saving the best for last.


I first saw Michael Ruppert in the film, End of Suburbia. That is the film that introduced me to the concept of Peak Oil. Peak Oil on a global scale is the point at which the rate of the world's oil production peaks. After the peak, no matter what the demand, the production will never increase and in fact will decrease.




It is likely that we have reached or will soon reach that point. The intersection of Peak Oil, economics and geopolitics is probably worth thinking about.



Regardless of what you think about 9/11 or the geopolitics of Peak Oil, you owe it to yourself to see the film,
Collapse. The film that tells the story of Michael Ruppert paints the portrait of human angst in the 21st century as civilization hangs by a thread.






His latest book on which the film is based is Confronting Collapse: The Crisis of Energy and Money in a Post Peak World.






The book and movie have given him a mainstream spotlight. Here is a good review of his book by ChelseaGreen.

But check this. He was interviewed in The Wall Street Journal. Here are reviews of his film in the New York Times and the LA Times. Plus a snarky review from Mark Jinkins of NPR. Roger Ebert's review is worth quoting:

I can only tell you I have a pretty good built-in B.S. detector, and its needle never bounced off zero while I watched this film. There is controversy over Ruppert, and he has many critics. But one simple fact at the center of his argument is obviously true, and it terrifies me. That fact: We have passed the peak of global oil resources.
Ruppert is the portrait of the biblical prophet who knows too much. Not only does he know it, but he can't stop talking about it.
If I say, ‘I will not mention him,
or speak any more in his name’,
then within me there is something like a burning fire
shut up in my bones;
I am weary with holding it in,
and I cannot. (Jeremiah 20:9)
The burning fire for Ruppert is Peak Oil and the imminent collapse of industrial civilization. Given that we are about two minutes from toast, 9/11 is really not that hard to believe. In fact, it is pretty much expected when an Empire in decline does what it knows how to do: control and dominate in order to secure access to the goods for its favored ones.

Remember, for Petroleum Man, it is always all about oil:

We are not "addicted" to oil -- the modern world is completely dependent upon it for our industrial agriculture systems, our transportation networks, and the global economy. Addictions are things you can give up -- but oil runs our civilization.
If you don't get Peak Oil, you don't get 9/11. In fact, you don't need to get 9/11 to get Peak Oil. Empire does not do what it does because it is evil. It does what it does, including all the dirty stuff (overthrow regimes, lie, deal drugs, assassinate people, cover up, destroy economies, deceive, and capitalize upon and/or engineer disasters to both numb and manipulate the populace) because it wants us to continue living the lifestyle to which we are accustomed.

Cell phones, cars, houses in the suburbs, cheap food, Burger King, and the internet are all good things, right? Empire has our interests at heart. This is what we want. Sometimes to make an omelet you have to break a few eggs. If we don't want to look at the broken eggs, we should just eat the omelet and thank the magic chicken.

  • If you don't want to know what it takes to turn on your light switch, then don't go here.
  • If you don't want to know why you can count on a tasty hamburger at every McDonald's, then don't go here.
  • If you don't want to know the geopolitical requirements to consume 20 million barrels of oil every day in a country that produces six, then don't read Michael Ruppert and all the other "crazy kooks" and "nutjobs" who are connecting the dots between a global economic system based on infinite growth, the peaking of finite resources, a planet of seven billion humans who all need more, and those who are in positions of power making decisions for us.
In light of all that, 9/11 is hardly a story.

But here it is anyway, according to Michael Ruppert.



Within two months of 9/11/2001, Ruppert gave a lecture at Portland State. It was made into a dvd,
Truth and Lies of 9/11.





That was followed by another dvd based on his lectures, Denial Stops Here: From 9/11 to Peak Oil and Beyond.





In 2004, he wrote Crossing the Rubicon: The Decline of the American Empire at the End of the Age of Oil. 700 pages. 1000 footnotes. I read it this summer which means that I am playing catch up. It also means that if a Presbyterian minister is writing about this book on a public blog that it may mean these ideas are making their way into the mainstream of public consciousness. That is one sign of hope.

In terms of catching up, Ruppert has left behind the "911 Truth" movement. He says he has nothing to do with it anymore. It isn't that he has changed his mind. Far from it. It is just that he thinks the current movement has been compromised with disinformation and that the window of opportunity for "legal and political change had closed."

For Ruppert, the important work now is helping people build
lifeboats. You can read the reasons why he distanced himself from the "911 Truth" movement on his blog post, Don't Paint Me With the 9-11 Truth Brush.



Ruppert was a detective for the LAPD.
Crossing the Rubicon is presented as a court case. The American people make up the jury. To make the case, you have to prove motive, means, and opportunity. Here is his case in a nutshell:




  1. Means - Dick Cheney and the Secret Service: Dick Cheney was running a completely separate chain of Command & Control via the Secret Service, assuring the paralysis of Air Force response on 9/11. The Secret Service has the technology to see the same radar screens the FAA sees in real time. They also have the legal authority and technological capability to take supreme command in cases of national emergency. Dick Cheney was the acting Commander in Chief on 9/11. (Click here for a summary of these points)

  2. Motive - Peak Oil: At some point between 2000 and 2007, world oil production reaches its peak; from that point on, every barrel of oil is going to be harder to find, more expensive to recover, and more valuable to those who recover and control it. Dick Cheney was well aware of the coming Peak Oil crisis at least as early as 1999, and 9/11 provided the pretext for the series of energy wars that Cheney stated, "will not end in our lifetime." (Click here for a summary of these points)

  3. Opportunity - 9/11 War Games: The Air Force was running multiple war games on the morning of 9/11 simulating hijackings over the continental United States that included (at least) one "live-fly" exercise as well as simulations that placed "false blips" on FAA radar screens. These war games eerily mirrored the real events of 9/11 to the point of the Air Force running drills involving hijacked aircraft as the 9/11 plot actually unfolded. The war games & terror drills played a critical role in ensuring no Air Force fighter jocks - who had trained their entire lives for this moment - would be able to prevent the attacks from succeeding. These exercises were under Dick Cheney's management. (Click here for a summary of these points)
Nowadays you can find Michael Ruppert in various places:
And that should do it for my 9/11 splash.

I will keep the links on the sidebar for a little while yet. No, I am not obsessed.

Call me a kook but I do think members of the previous administration should have been impeached for covering up information related to the 9/11 attacks. I think the cover-up implied guilt. Presented with Ruppert's book vs. the 911 Commission Report, this member of the jury will side with Ruppert.

So what now? There should have been and still should be an independent investigation. A real one this time. Will it happen? Not likely.


Is the truth regarding 9/11 important? Yes.

But what is really important is for us to understand the effects of 9/11 and the reason for our military presence all over the world including the Middle East.

The reason still exists.


In the words of Roger Ebert:

We have passed the peak of global oil resources. There are only so many known oil reserves. We have used up more than half of them. Remaining reserves are growing smaller, and the demand is growing larger. It took about a century to use up the first half. That usage was much accelerated in the most recent 50 years. Now the oil demands of giant economies like India and China are exploding. They represent more than half the global population, and until recent decades had small energy consumption.

If the supply is finite, and usage is potentially doubling, you do the math.
Here is some math:
Now some questions:
  • What is the price tag for the lifestyle to which we have become accustomed?
  • To what lengths will those in power go to maintain that disparity of consumption for as long as possible?
  • How long will that last?
Empire has a simple answer to those questions. Like a cancer, It only knows how to grow. Empire will control, dominate, and secure as much as possible for those whom it favors.

Compared to what we are facing, 9/11 was child's play.

I don't think that is a good answer.

It is up to you and it is up to me to make a different future possible for our children.

Thursday, September 09, 2010

Paul Thompson and The Jersey Girls


I am spending this week leading up to the ninth anniversary of September 11th, 2001 offering some of my thoughts about 9/11. I thought I would do it by offering introductions to people who on our behalf are asking questions that the media has not.

On the sidebar is a link to the film, 9/11: Press For Truth. This film tells the story of the Jersey Girls. These are four women whose husbands were killed on September 11th when airplanes hit the World Trade Center towers. Here is the trailer to the film.



These four women (pictured in the right from the
cover of Ms. Magazine) had questions. How could the military have allowed this to happen? How could it be prevented in the future?


They expected the justice department to answer these kinds of questions. They didn't get answers. Finally they pressured Congress to form a special committee to investigate. They succeeded in urging Congress to form the 911 Commission.

However, it didn't take long before they realized that the 911 Commission was less interested in investigating the issues as it was providing cover for the government.
This was not a surprise considering that the executive director of the commission was Philip Zelikow who had close ties with the administration and was a personal friend of Condoleeza Rice. Zelikow was the gate keeper for who would be interviewed and what topics would be addressed.


The resulting
911 Commission Report did not answer The Jersey Girls' questions.


The Jersey Girls are not "crazy conspiracy theorists" or left wing radicals. Two of them had voted in 2000 for Bush/Cheney. They are four women who sought justice and answers from our government and were stonewalled. Thankfully, they are still seeking answers and they are not being silenced by ridicule, snark, or pressure. In my book, they are true American patriots.



The film,
9/11 Press For Truth also tells the story of Paul Thompson. Thompson is an independent researcher who created a The 9/11 Timeline.




The timeline is a catalog of mainstream news accounts about people, events and places related to the events of 9/11 and the ensuing response. He found that buried in mainstream news accounts are many important pieces of information that are not noticed. His timeline brings them to light.





In 2004, Thompson put his timeline in book form, The Terror Timeline: Year By Year, Day By Day, Minute By Minute.






This has been a key resource for those who do have questions about 9/11. It was Thompson's timeline that convinced David Griffin to begin his research.


Here is an interview with Paul Thompson by Peter Coyote of Link TV.

Pretty insightful. Watch all three parts:
Part 1
Part 2
Part 3