Shuck and Jive

Friday, July 09, 2010

IPMN Responds to Assembly's Approval of Middle East Study Committee Report

The Middle East Peace Report was setting up to be one of the most bitterly divided issues at General Assembly. As it turned out, there was much conversation and compromise and a reworked report was approved unanimously by the committee and approved by 82% of the commissioners.

Here is a press release from the Israel/Palestine Mission Network:

Unprecedented Agreement at 219th GA from Previously Divided Voices

A week ago, it looked as if the Presbyterian Church (USA) was going to enact a version of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict within its own body, so divided were we on all sides. For some of us, the Middle East Study Committee’s report was a long-awaited recognition of the suffering of the Palestinian people, particularly our Christian brothers and sisters, and a stirring call to action and solidarity. For others of us, the report seemed indifferent to Israeli concerns for a secure homeland and the Church’s ongoing relationship with the Jewish community. Coming into the Assembly, some of us were lined up to push the report through; others of us were determined to defeat it.

Today, we still have disagreements on items in the report, on methods we should pursue, on arguments we should make. But today, by God’s grace, we have discovered that together, we may actually be more faithful and effective in seeking peace with justice for both Palestinians and Israelis than separately. To that end, we stand together in support of the report as amended by the Middle East Issues Committee as witness to a new way of approaching this intractable problem and, indeed, a new way of being the Church.

We have learned that we do not have to choose between our commitments. We have learned that we can risk trusting people with whom we were afraid to engage. We have learned that addressing the conflict in the Middle East cannot be a question of winners and losers. We must model how the conflict itself will be resolved: if someone loses, everyone loses. Beyond any expectation, we find ourselves discovering a new model of ministry together, a model committed to seeking, hearing, and responding to the fullness of narratives and commitments with the Palestinian and Israeli peoples, Jews, Christians and Muslims.

Through Isaiah, God says, “See, I am doing a new thing! Now it springs forth; do you not perceive it? I am making a way in the desert and rivers in the wilderness.” Let us all give thanks for this new thing that God is doing and commit ourselves anew to work together for peace with justice.

Carol Hylkema, Moderator, Israel/Palestine Mission Network
Ron Shive, Chair, Middle East Study Committee
Bill Harter, Co-Convener, Presbyterians for Middle East Peace
Katharine Henderson, President, Auburn Theological Seminary
Read John Harris' comments on the work of this committee here and here.


  1. The really interesting thing about this statement are the signatories at the bottom. I didn't know that Bill Harter even talked with people from the IPMN much less signed letters together! Plus earlier in the week Dr. Henderson made a speech about how terrible the MESC report was.

    What is even more amazing is that on this issue the normal liberal/conservative thing just doesn't happen. I have Evangelical friends who won't even discuss Israel/Palestine with me and others who will support the change in G-6.0106b who work with me on Israel/Palestine issues. Although I have to say that those who support gay and lesbian issues are now confusing people by being from the whole theological spectrum too. Go figure.

  2. I don't usually talk like this, but all this mixing up of categories might be the work of Spirit!

    Peace be with you, Bob!

  3. Yes, John, there is Spirit, a Holy One at that. And the GA ordinarly gets quite a dose of its presence. Aleluia.

    Of course we are disappointed with some of the results but democracy does work and the people, in this case commissioners, do get it right sooner or later. The Spirit is blessing us and we will all be bathed in the Light, more and more Light!

    We need people like you to keep pushing the enbvelope. You do it with intelligence, creativity, humor, sensitivity and compassion. Very Presbyterian. Very Christian. Very Spiritual.

  4. What Israel is doing IS apartheid. No doubt about it. It does need to be named as such.

  5. Thanks John. I really appreciate the words of support!

    We did make national news regarding our statement on Israel/Palestine.

    LA Times