Their actions against sexual and gender minorities, science, reproductive choice and so forth are connected with their superstition. Which comes first: religious superstition or ignorance? Hard to know, but they do feed off each other.
My real objection to the whole thing is the mixing of religious superstition with public ceremonies. Is the nation well-served by a bunch of preachers parading about at national events?
The political reality is that our nation is made up of superstitious people whose superstition compels them to foist it on others. We will have to live with this for some time to come. Perhaps having to endure the dangerous superstition of Warren will wake us up to the danger of superstition itself.
If Obama had done the right thing and invited me to give the invocation, here is what I would have said:
I offer no prayer to any deity. Those who wish to pray may do so on their own. Instead, I invite us to celebrate and to contemplate the virtues of reason, justice, equality, and compassion that are available to all human beings.
The challenges we face are immense.
May we put away selfishness, greed, and short-sightedness.
May we work together against all forms of tyranny.
May we seek as our highest and our common goal the well-being of future generations.
May we work as tirelessly for the rights of others as for our own.
May we find a way to live within our means, with one another, with our non-human relatives, and with Earth.
And may we discover the courage, intelligence, imagination, and compassion available within us and among us to face the great work that lies ahead.
How beautiful. And appropriate to recognize that prayer is meant to bring us in line with God as He is already in line with us. The Rick Warrens of the world do not recognize that. My God is Love and I Love you for your stances (well most of them) and your willingness to stand up for others.
ReplyDeleteI put this comment on my blog following your comment (In case you didn't see it)
Yes John, I still admire 99% of your stance. Just not this one.
We need more John Shuck's in the world and less Rick Warrens. Someday I would love to sit in your congregation and hear you preach. Have a wonderful blessed Christmas of Love. j
As a non-theist, this sounds far more inclusive to me than anything likely to come from Warren's lips.
ReplyDeleteThe creationists are likely to have a fit about 'non-human relatives'. I might have used 'fellow animals' except that does tend to exclude bacteria and plants that your wording includes.
Let’s just do away with prayer at the inauguration. Problem solved. We are pluralist society. Christian prayer or any prayer is inappropriate for this momentous event.
ReplyDeleteJohn McNeese
Thanks Jay, 99% isn't too bad!
ReplyDeleteErp, never want to leave out a single bacterium.
Johnm, this was really my point.
As a bit of research I looked up what I could find about prayers at
ReplyDeleteinaugurations. I found this by Newdow which looks fairly reliable and
I thought you might find it interesting (though I suspect our
non-human relatives won't).
http://www.restorethepledge.com/live/past_litigation/inaugural/docs/2004-12-17%20complaint.pdf
(Appendix D. The whole thing includes notes such as on Cardinal
Cushing taking 12 minutes for his Invocation in 1961 [I think some
sermons have been shorter] or on Rev. Sherrill who apparently said
afterwards that he thought the whole thing was bad for religion. He in
turn cites Medhurst, Martin Jay "God Bless the President: The Rhetoric of
Inaugural Prayer" PhD thesis (The Pennsylvania State University, 1980))
Elsewhere I found something that indicated ministers started showing
up in 1933. Note the balancing between a Catholic and a Protestant
later expanded to include a Rabbi and then an Orthodox archbishop.
Most recently it seems to be two Protestant ministers (or one
Protestant minister doing two prayers). The last rabbi and Catholic
seems to have been 1985 (which also includes, I think, the only one
openly gay though he wasn't open then).
INAUGURAL CLERGY
January 20, 1937 inaugural of Franklin D. Roosevelt
Invocation by:Chaplain ZeBarney Phillips
Benediction by:Father John A. Ryan
January 20, 1941 inaugural of Franklin D. Roosevelt
Invocation by: Chaplain ZeBarney Phillips
Benediction by: Father Michael J. Ready
January 20, 1945 inaugural of Franklin D. Roosevelt
Invocation by: Bishop Angus Dun
Benediction by: Monsignor John A. Ryan
January 20, 1949 inaugural of Harry S. Truman
Invocation by: Rev. Edward Hughes Pruden
Prayer by: Rabbi Samuel Thurman
Benediction by: Father Patick A. O’Boyle
January 20, 1953 inaugural of Dwight D. Eisenhower
Invocation by: Father Patrick A. O’Boyle
Prayer by: Rabbi Abba Hillel Silver
Prayer by: President Eisenhower
Benediction by: Rev. Henry Knox Sherrill
January 21, 1957 inaugural of Dwight D. Eisenhower
Invocation by: Rev. Edward L. R. Elson
Prayer by: His Eminence Michael
Prayer by Rabbi Louis Finkelstein
Benediction by: Edward Cardinal Mooney
January 20, 1961 inaugural of John F. Kennedy
Invocation by: Richard Cardinal Cushing
Prayer by: His Eminence Iakovos
Prayer by John Barclay
Benediction by: Rabbi Nelson Glueck
January 20, 1965 inaugural of Lyndon B. Johnson
Invocation by: Archbishop Robert E. Lucey
Prayer by: Rabbi Hyman Judah Schachtel
Prayer by Rev. Dr. George R. Davis
Benediction by: His Eminence Iakovos
January 20, 1969 inaugural of Richard M. Nixon
Invocation by: Rev. Charles Ewbank Tucker
Prayer by: Rabbi Edgar F. Magnin
Prayer by His Eminence Iakovos
Prayer by Rev. Billy Graham
Benediction by: Archbishop Terence J. Cooke
January 20, 1973 inaugural of Richard M. Nixon
Invocation by: Rev. E.V. Hill
Prayer by: Rabbi Seymour Siegel
Prayer by His Eminence Iakovos
Benediction by: Archbishop Terence J. Cooke
January 20, 1977 inaugural of James E. Carter
Invocation by: Rev. William Cannon
Benediction by: Rev. John R. Roach
January 20, 1981 inaugural of Ronald W. Reagan
Invocation by: Rev. Donn. Moomaw
Benediction by: Rev. Donn. Moomaw
January 21, 1985 inaugural of Ronald W. Reagan
Invocation by: Rev. Timothy S. Healy
Prayer by: Rabbi Alfred Gottschalk
Prayer by: Rev. Donn. Moomaw
Benediction by: Rev. Peter Gomes
January 20, 1989 inaugural of George H. W. Bush
Invocation by: Rev. Billy Graham
Benediction by: Rev. Billy Graham
January 20, 1993 inaugural of William J. Clinton
Invocation by: Rev. Billy Graham
Benediction by: Rev. Billy Graham
January 20, 1997 inaugural of William J. Clinton
Invocation by: Rev. Billy Graham
Benediction by: Rev. Gardner C. Taylor
January 20, 2001 inaugural of George W. Bush
Invocation by: Rev. Franklin Graham
Benediction by: Pastor Kirbyjon H. Caldwell
January 20, 2005 inaugural of George W. Bush
Invocation by: Rev. Louis Leon
Benediction by: Pastor Kirbyjon H. Caldwell
I don't have my copy of The Defining Moment available (quel scandale), but as I recall, FDR had the headmaster of his high school (Groton), The Rev. Endicott Peabody, do the invocation in 1933.
ReplyDeleteErp,
ReplyDeleteThanks for all that! It seems that we have become less diverse in terms of religious presence as time passes.
Probably less intelligent too.