Shuck and Jive

Thursday, January 08, 2009

Israel Broke Ceasefire First

Here is a statement with some teeth from the Israel Palestine Mission Network of the Presbyterian Church (USA). You can read it here in pdf.

The Israel Palestine Mission Network of the Presbyterian Church (USA) condemns in the harshest terms possible the Israeli massacre of Palestinians now underway in Gaza. This long-planned and all-too-indiscriminate slaughter of hundreds of civilians, the wounding of thousands, and the destruction of homes, hospitals, schools, mosques and economic infrastructure cannot be justified in the name of Israeli national security.

The numbers simply do not add up: In the past eight years 20 Israelis have been killed by Hamas rockets while in the past three years over 1700 Palestinians in Gaza have been killed by the Israeli military, including the 600 men, women and children who have died so far in this most recent attack. Hundreds more have died as a result of the Israeli embargo on medicine, food and fuel. The sheer disproportion of death and destruction is an affront to the conscience of humanity. This blatant collective punishment mocks international law as well as the Geneva Conventions. It is morally repugnant to us and the rest of the world.

Despite the usual "blaming" justifications given for this incursion, there are other truths about Israel's actions that need to be told:

1) Israel, not Hamas, broke the truce*, and has long used its own missiles to assassinate Palestinian leaders, often with family-destroying "collateral damage."

2) The attacks on Gaza coincide with a heated Israeli political campaign in which the leaders of the Labor and Kadima Parties must appear to the electorate to be as tough as the Likud Party led by Benjamin Netanyahu.

3) The current United States government has become complicit in this tragedy by supporting Israel's justifications for its actions and by—alone in the nations of the UN Security Council— blocking the international demand for a ceasefire.

4) The timing reflects a desire to limit the restoration of human rights and international diplomacy promised by the incoming Obama Administration.

The Israel Palestine Mission Network of the Presbyterian Church (USA), in accordance with the Gospel of Jesus Christ, stands with the victims of this atrocious massacre. We condemn violence committed by both sides, but cannot turn a blind eye to the disproportionate amount of suffering on the Palestinian side of this equation. The simple fact is that the firing of the most lethal, hi-tech weapons on earth into an embargoed, walled-in Gaza by Israeli forces is tantamount to what is crudely known as "shooting fish in a barrel."

We call upon the government of the United States of America to support an immediate cease-fire within the United Nations and independently. We also call for a multi-national peacekeeping force to be installed as soon as possible, which is the standard that has been set anywhere else in the world following such a tragic humanitarian disaster. We call upon the Israeli government to allow UN peacekeeping forces with humanitarian assistance to enter into Gaza immediately.

The statement includes two links: CNN Finally Confirms Israel Broke Ceasefire First

And this one: "NPR News Monday, January 5, 2009"

MARGARET WARNER: Staying with you, you know the Hamas leadership, or certainly some Hamas officials, I think better than anyone we've had on our program so far.

Explain their thinking in -- did they intend to provoke this conflict in the first place in mid-December, when they intensified the rocket attacks on southern Israel? That has been one popular conception, certainly in many Israeli and foreign circles.

MARK PERRY: That is a popular notion, but it doesn't accord with the facts. During the six months of the cease-fire, there were 153 violations of the cease-fire by Israel, and 36 Palestinians in Gaza were killed by Israeli forces. Most important of all, the economic siege of Gaza continued.

Hamas officials went to Egypt, asked them to intervene to stop the siege, or they would have to take action. No one listened, so they did increase their rocket fire.

But if we want to assess blame here, this is not all on Hamas. They've suffered enormous casualties. The people in Gaza are suffering. That's not in their interest. What they wanted to do was lift the siege and allow the Palestinian people to breathe, and they're hoping that this will be the result.


  1. I am so glad to see these things coming out in mainstream media, and to see this committee of the PC(USA) making such a strong statement.

    People have GOT to hear about the absolute atrocities the Israeli governments have exacted on the people of Gaza.

    And I am hoping in 12 days the new Obama administration will come out with a strong condemnation and full support of UN involvement.

  2. Zionists are masters of the lie. They have it down to a science.
    Reference Victor Ostrovsky's book "By Way of Deception"
    If anyone doesn't understand the Zionist way, they will once they read it.

    I offer the PNAC's manifesto for "Regime Change" in Iraq as one of the foremost deadly lies to come from that brood.
    Go ahead, read the names if you don't already know them. Some "Christian", most "Jewish" some other. All Zionist.
    All some of the most deranged and depraved people in this country. Doing the bidding of some of the most deranged and depraved people in Israel and elsewhere.

    Israelis want peace, Palestinians want peace...we all want peace.
    Zionism cannot coexist with peace.
    And therein lies the root of this problem.

  3. Devil's advocate moment:

    In the interest of disclosure, is the Israel/Palestine Mission Network actually part of the PC(USA) or is it an independent advocacy group?

    It drives me crazy when those we disagree with cloak themselves in order to look like something out of Louisville. It's only fair to point it out when others do it as well.

    The actual statement out of the church leadership is a little more restrained.

    I think the PC(USA) may have learned the wrong lesson from the PR fiasco that was divestment, but it wouldn't be the first time.

  4. Hey Fly,

    This is from its website:

    "Established by action of the 2004 General Assembly, the Israel/Palestine Mission Network encourages congregations and presbytery mission committees, task groups and other entities toward specific mission goals that will create currents of wider and deeper involvement with Israel/Palestine."

    They have the PC(USA) name on it.

    I have posted the letter from our stated clerk as well. Thanks!